Reading Lists and Comments
Dave Winer has been writing about reading lists lately as he tackles a new aggregator hack of his OPML Editor. As he has been working on that, I have found myself commenting on more blogs than ever before: either for work or to add to the interesting discussions happening in the library community. I was never a big commenter in the past…
Reading lists are a way to have an updated OPML file in your aggregator at all times. Usually, when you grab an OPML, you have to do so every few days if you want it to be fresh. Doing this manually is time-consuming and annoying. Subscribing to a reading list will ensure a fresh OPML file is being used by your aggregator as it updates automatically.
The two (reading lists and blog comments) collided in my brain this morning on the way to work. Here’s what the thought process.
1) I want to follow the comments that I am making on blogs.
2) I don’t want to grab the feeds for those comments (if available) because I will forget to unsubscribe to them and they will sit in my aggregator, sucking on the limited bandwidth that I have to work with.
3) I want to be able to easily subscribe to a comment feed and then have it automatically deleted when the conversation is over.
4) Enter reading lists.
5) I could create a separate OPML file for all of the comment feeds that I want to track.
6) After a certain number of days with no comments to any blog post that I subscribed to, the feeds would automatically be deleted from the reading list.
7) What would be even better is if (somehow) I could automatically append my OPML comment reading list when I make a comment on a blog post. Wow!
This is just an idea and I haven’t fleshed out all of the details yet, but I think the concept works. Also, as I read more about reading lists, the more I see it as way to create hierarchical lists of content. Blogs are a perfect place to start. This evening, Dave writes:
New verbiage about reading lists. “It’s a way for readers to delegate the act of subscribing to experts in subjects they are interested in.”
While experts is a relative term (experts based on what?), I think he’s onto something here. Trying to catalog blogs is very hard to do. Reading lists might just be the thing to do it well. I think that there is a piece missing though…maybe the manual creation of the lists?


Recent Comments